Regulae ad Eosdem Spiritus Discernendos (Ad Secundam Hebdomadam)
Regulae ad Eosdem Spiritus Discernendos (Ad Secundam Hebdomadam)
Other useful guidelines for a fuller discernment of spirits, especially suitable for the second week. The first is that it is proper to God and to each good angel to truly infuse spiritual joy into the soul, which they move, after all sadness and disturbance have been removed, a disturbance that the devil has caused, while here, on the contrary, some sophistical arguments, preferring the appearance of truth, often oppose that joy found in the soul. Second, it is solely God's to console the soul, with no prior cause of consolation, since this is the Creator's own prerogative: to enter into His creation and wholly transform it into love for Himself, drawing it and changing it. We say that there is no cause preceding it when there is nothing in our senses, intellect, or will that could cause such consolation by itself. Third, whenever the cause of consolation has preceded, its author can be either a bad angel or a good one, but they aim at opposing ends: the good one, so that the soul may grow in good thoughts and actions; the bad one, so that it may act wrongly and perish. Fourth, it's the nature of a wicked spirit to first appear as an angel of light, transforming itself, and once it knows the good intentions of the soul, to initially entice it, and then gradually lead it to its own perverse desires. Indeed, it simulates from the very beginning to follow and nurture the good and holy thoughts of a person, but then it gradually entangles them in hidden snares of its own deceit. Fifth, we must diligently and carefully examine our thoughts regarding their beginning, middle, and end. If these three aspects are in order, it’s a sign from the good angels suggesting those thoughts. However, if during our mental discourse something arises that is inherently evil, or that distracts us from good, or pushes us toward something less good than what our soul had previously intended to follow, or if it tires, angers, or disturbs the soul, removing the peace, calm, and tranquility that were present before, then it will be clear evidence that a malignant spirit is the author of such thoughts, as it is always opposed to our benefit and salvation. Sixth, whenever you find yourself sensing the enemy in some suggestion with its serpentine tail, that is, with an evil end that it always tries to insinuate into us, it’s very helpful to review the entire discourse and note what it initially pretended to be good thoughts, and how it gradually sought to remove the sweetness of spiritual taste and the serenity of the soul, and to infuse its poison, so that through this kind of experience, you can more easily guard against its known deceptions in the future. Seventh, both spirits insinuate themselves into the souls of those who promote the good of salvation in different ways: the good spirit gently, peacefully, and sweetly, like a drop of water slipping into a sponge; the evil spirit, however, harshly, restlessly, and violently, with a certain noise, like rain falling on a rock: for those who tend daily toward worse things, the exact opposite happens. The reason for this diversity is that the disposition of the soul is similar to an angel in one way, or dissimilar in another. For if either spirit finds something contrary to itself, it joins itself to that with noise and a pulse that can be easily noticed. If it conforms, however, it enters quietly, as if into its own open home. Whenever consolation comes to us without any prior cause, even if it seems to be sent from God, we must still carefully and diligently distinguish this present moment of consolation from the next, in which the soul still burns with longing and feels the remnants of divine favor recently received. For it often happens in this later time that we may feel or deliberate about something either from habit, discourse, and our own judgment, or from the prompting of good or evil spirits, which, since they do not come from God directly, require careful discernment before we give our assent or act on them.
Read the original Latin
Regulae aliae utiles ad pleniorem Spirituum discretionem, et secundae hebdomadae potissimum convenientes.
Prima est, quod proprium est Dei, et Angeli cujusque boni veram infundere spiritualem laetitiam; animae, quam movent, sublata tristitia et perturbatione omni, quam ingessit daemon, cum hic e contrario sophisticis argumentis quibusdam, veri speciem praeferentibus, laetitiam illam in anima repertam oppugnare soleat.
Secunda, solius est Dei consolari animam, nulla praecedente consolationis causa, cum sit hoc proprium Creatoris, suam ingredi creaturam, et illam in amorem sui totam convertere, trahere, et mutare. Causam vero praecedere nullam tunc dicimus, quando nec sensibus, nec intellectui, neque voluntati nostrae quidquam objectum est, quod ejusmodi consolationem causare ex se possit.
Tertia, quoties praecessit consolationis causa, auctor ejus potest existere tam malus Angelus, quam bonus, sed ad fines tendunt contrarios: bonus quidem, ut anima in boni cogitatione, et operatione magis proficiat, malus autem, ut male agat illa, et pereat.
Quarta, id moris est spiritui maligno, ut in lucis Angelum transfigurans sese, cognitis piis animae votis, primum obsecundet, mox inde ad perversa sua desideria illam alliciat. Simulat etenim ab initio bonas sanctasque hominis cogitationes sequi, et fovere, at deinde in occultas fallaciarum suarum pedicas paulatim tractura illaqueat.
Quinta, sedulo et accurate excutiendae sunt cogitationes nostrae, circa principium, medium et finem suum, quae tria si recte se habeant, Angeli boni argumentum est, cogitationes illas suggerentis: sin autem per discursum mentis aliquid offertur, vel sequitur, quod ex se malum sit, vel avocet a bono, vel ad minus bonum impellat, quam anima prius quaerendo sequi decrevisset, vel animam ipsam defatiget, angat, ac perturbet, sublata quae prius aderat, quiete, pace, et tranquillitate, evidens tunc erit indicium, auctorem esse cogitationis ejusmodi spiritum malignum, utpote utilitati, et saluti nostrae semper adversantem.
Sexta, quoties contingit in aliqua suggestione deprehendi hostem ex cauda sua serpentina, id est fine malo, quem semper nobis insinuare studet, tunc plurimum juvat revolvere discursum totum, et notare quid ab initio praetexuerit bonae cogitationis, et quomodo praecedentem spiritualis gustus suavitatem, animi serenitatem sensim amovere, ac venenum suum infundere tentarit, ut per hujusmodi experimentum cognitae illius fraudes facilius deinceps caveantur.
Septima, eorum, qui promovent in bona salutis, animis se insinuat uterque spiritus diverso modo, bonus quidem leniter, placide, ac suaviter, sicut aquae stilla in spongiam illabens, malus vero duriter, implacide, et violenter, cum strepitu quodam, sicut imber decidens in petram: illis autem, qui in dies tendunt in deterius, oppositum prorsus usuvenit. Cujus sane diversitatis ratio est, quatenus Angelo utrilibet similis est, vel dissimilis animae ipsius dispositio. Si enim contraria sibi eam alteruter spiritus invenerit, cum strepitu et pulsu, qui facile adverti queat, ei se conjungit. Si conformem vero, tanquam in propriam, et apertam domum subit cum quiete.
Octava, quoties sine praevia ulla causa consolatio nobis adest, quamvis ei, tanquam divinitus immissae, ut supra dictum est, nihil fallaciae subesse possit, debemus tamen attente, ac sollicite distinguere praesens consolationis tempus a proximo sequente, in quo anima fervet adhuc, et favoris divini nuper accepti sentit reliquias. Nam posteriore hoc tempore frequenter accidit, ut vel ex habitu, discursu, et judicio proprio, vel ex boni, aut mali spiritus instinctu, aliqua sentiamus, vel deliberemus, quae cum ab ipso Deo, citra medium non emanent, solerti indigent discussione, priusquam recipiant assensum, vel in opus veniant.
The Spiritual Exercises companion
Keep the Examen going after day 14
Chosen Portion delivers a short daily portion — including Examen prompts and texts from the Exercises — free on iOS.
Ignatius built the Exercises around a fixed daily portion of prayer and review; Chosen Portion turns that same structure into an evening Examen habit on your phone.
- A guided 5-step Examen prompt every evening
- Daily portions from the Exercises and 77 other historic works
- Track a 14-day discernment streak alongside the course