Upon the Earl of Strafford's death
The Burden of Political Expediency
The King reflects on his decision to sign the death warrant for the Earl of Strafford, acknowledging it as a failure of conscience driven by fear of man.
I viewed the Lord of Strafford as a gentleman whose great abilities might make a prince more afraid than ashamed to employ him in the most important affairs of state.1 For those abilities tended to give him great confidence in what he undertook, and that was likely enough to lead him into serious errors and many enemies—of which he could hardly help gathering a large number. While he moved in so high a sphere, and with so brilliant a light, he was bound, like the sun, to raise many envious vapors, which, thickened by popular hatred, could cast a cloud over even the brightest merit and integrity. Although I cannot, in my judgment, approve of everything he did—driven, perhaps, more by the necessities of the times and the temper of the people than by his own inclination toward severity and rigor—I could never be convinced that he was so criminal that I would willingly expose his life to the stroke of justice and the malice of his enemies. I never faced a more unhappy situation than in the business of that unfortunate Earl. Caught between my own dissatisfaction of conscience and the necessity—as some told me—of satisfying the pressing demands of others, I was persuaded by those who I believe wished me well to choose what was safe rather than what seemed just, preferring the outward peace of my kingdoms with men to that inward exactness of conscience before God.2 And indeed, I am so far from excusing or denying that compliance on my part (for it was not full consent) to his destruction—whom in my judgment I did not think, by any clear law, guilty of death—that I never felt any touch of conscience with greater regret. As a sign of my repentance, I have often confessed it with sorrow both to God and to people, as an act of such sinful frailty that it revealed more a fear of man than of God—whose name and place on earth no one is worthy to bear who would avoid the inconveniences of the state by acts of such high injustice that no public convenience can expiate or compensate.34 I see it as a bad exchange to wound a man's own conscience in order to heal the sores of the state—to calm the storms of popular discontent by stirring up a tempest in a man's own heart. God's justice has not failed, in the outcome and its sad consequences, to show the world the fallacy of that maxim: it's better that one man perish—even unjustly—than that the people be displeased or destroyed. For in all likelihood I could never have suffered greater calamities with my people—yet with greater comfort—had I vindicated Strafford's innocence, at least by refusing to sign that destructive Bill according to the justice my conscience urged on me, than I have suffered since I gratified some men's ungrateful importunities with so cruel a favor.5 And I have observed that those who counseled me to sign that Bill have been so far from receiving the rewards of such attempts to win the people's favor that no men have been harassed and crushed more than they. Only he has been least troubled by them who counseled me not to consent against the judgment of my own conscience. I hope God has forgiven me and them the sinful rashness of that business.6
Learning from Divine Judgment
The King interprets his subsequent sufferings as a divine call to prioritize justice and conscience over political preservation.
With this fully conscious in my soul, the judgments God has seen fit to send upon me are all the more welcome as a means—I hope—that his mercy has sanctified for me, to lead me to repent of that unjust act (for it was that to me), and to teach me for the future that the best rule of policy is to prefer doing justice over all enjoyments, and the peace of my conscience over the preservation of my kingdoms. Nothing has more strengthened my resolve against all those fierce, pressing demands that have since sought to win a similar consent from me to acts in which my conscience is not satisfied, than the sharp pangs I have felt for what I allowed in my Lord of Strafford's case.78 Not that I was determined to employ him in my affairs against the advice of my Parliament, but I would not have had any hand in his death, of whose innocence I was more certain than any man living could be. Nor were the crimes charged against him clear enough that, after a long and fair hearing, they could give convincing satisfaction to the majority of both Houses—especially the Lords, of whom barely a third were present when the bill passed that House. And as for the House of Commons, many gentlemen, ready enough to diminish my Lord of Strafford's greatness and power, yet unconvinced of his guilt in law, did not dare condemn him to death. For their integrity in their votes, by the posting of their names, they were exposed to popular slander, hatred, and fury—which then grew so excessive in its clamors for justice (that is, to make both myself and the two Houses vote and do as they would have us) that many, it's thought, were terrified into siding with the condemning party rather than satisfied that they were right to do so. And that later Act, which vacated the authority of the precedent so it could not be imitated later, is enough to tell the world that some remorse touched even his most implacable enemies—knowing he had been given very hard measure, and such as they would be very unwilling to have repeated against themselves.9 This tenderness and regret I find in my soul for having any hand—and that very unwillingly, God knows—in shedding one man's blood unjustly (though under the color and formalities of justice, and pretenses of avoiding public harm), which may, I hope, be some evidence before God and man, to all posterity, that I am far from justly bearing the vast load and guilt of all that blood which has been shed in this unhappy war, which some men insist on charging to me to ease their own souls—I who am, and always will be, more afraid to take away any man's life unjustly than to lose my own.
A Prayer for Penitence and Restoration
The King concludes with a heartfelt prayer of confession, seeking God's mercy and the cleansing of his conscience through the blood of Christ.
But then, O God, of your infinite mercies, forgive me that act of sinful compliance, which has greater aggravations on me than on any man, since I had not the least temptation of envy or malice against him, and by my place I should at least have been so far a protector of him as to refuse my consent to his destruction. Lord, I acknowledge my transgression, and my sin is always before me.✦ Deliver me from blood-guiltiness, O God, God of my salvation, and my tongue will sing of your righteousness. I have sinned against you and done this evil in your sight, for you saw the contradiction between my heart and my hand. Yet don't cast me away from your presence; purge me with the blood of my Redeemer, and I will be clean; wash me with that precious outpouring, and I will be whiter than snow.✦10 Teach me to learn righteousness by your judgments, and to see my frailty in your justice: while I was persuaded to prevent later troubles by shedding one man's blood, you have for that, among other sins, brought upon me and upon my kingdoms great, long, and heavy troubles. Make me prefer justice, which is your will, before all contrary clamors, which are only the disclosures of man's injurious will. It's already too much that they once overcame me, so that I pleased them by displeasing You. O never allow me, for any reason of state, to go against the reason of my conscience—which is to sin gravely against You, the God of reason and Judge of our consciences. Whatever, O Lord, you see fit to take from me, still restore to me the joy of your salvation and always uphold me with your free Spirit—which subjects my will to nothing but the light of reason, justice, and religion that shines in my soul—for you desire truth in the inward parts and integrity in outward expression.11 Lord, hear the voice of your children, and the blood of my Savior, which speaks better things; O make me and my people hear the voice of joy and gladness, so that the bones you have broken may rejoice in your salvation.✦✦
Read the original Latin
I looked upon my Lord of Strafford, as a Gentleman, whose great abilities might make a Prince rather afraid, then ashamed to employ him in the greatest affairs of State.
For those were prone to create in him great confidence of undertakings, and this was like enough to betray him to great errors, and many enemies; whereof he could not but contract good store, while moving in so high a sphear, and with so vigorous a lustre, he must needs (as the Sun) raise many envious exhalations, which condensed by a popular odium, were capable to cast a cloud before the brightest merit and integrity.
Though I cannot in my judgement approve all he did, driven (it may be) by the necessities of times, and the Temper of that people, more then led by his own disposition to any height and rigour of actions: yet I could never be convinced of any such criminousness in him as willingly to expose his life to the stroke of Justice, and malice of his enemies. I never met with a more unhappy conjuncture of affairs, then in the businesse of that unfortunate Earl: when between my own unsatisfiedness in Conscience, and a necessity (as some told me) of satisfying the importunities of some people, I was perswaded by those that I think wished Me well, to chuse rather what was safe, then what seemed just; preferring the outward peace of My Kingdoms with men, before that inward exactness of Conscience before God.
And indeed I am so far from excusing or denying that compliance on My part (for plenary consent it was not) to his destruction, whom in My judgment I thought not, by any clear law, guilty of death: That I never bare any touch of Conscience with greater regret: which as a sign of my repentance, I have often with sorrow confessed both to God and men, as an act of so sinfull frailty, that it discovered more a fear of man, then of God, whose name and place on earth no man is worthy to bear, who will avoid inconveniencies of State, by acts of so high injustice, as no publick convenience can expiate or compensate.
I see it a bad exchange to wound a mans own Conscience, thereby to salve State-sores; to calm the storms of popular discontents, by stirring up a tempest in a mans own bosome.
Nor hath Gods Justice failed in the event and sad consequences, to shew the world the fallacy of that Maxime, Better one man perish, (though unjustly) then the people be displeased or destroyed.
For, In all likelihood I could never have suffered, with My people, greater calamities, (yet with greater comfort) had I vindicated Straffords innocency, at least by denying to Sign that destructive Bill, according to that Justice, which My conscience suggested to Me, then I have done since I gratified some mens unthankful importunities with so cruel a favour. And I have observed, that those, who counselled Me to sign that Bill, have been so far from receiving the rewards of such ingratiatings with the People, that no men have been harassed & crushed more then they: He onely hath been least vexed by them, who counselled Me, not to consent against the vote of My own Conscience: I hope God hath forgiven Me and them, the sinful rashness of that business.
To which being in My soul so fully conscious, those Judgements God hath pleased to send upon Me, are so much the more welcom, as a means (I hope) which his mercy hath sanctified so to Me, as to make Me repent of that unjust Act, (for so it was to Me) and for the future to teach Me, That the best rule of policie is, to prefer the doing of Justice, before all enjoyments, and the peace of my Conscience before the preservation of My Kingdoms.
Nor hath any thing more fortified My resolutions against all those violent importunities, which since have sought to gain a like consent from Me, to Acts, wherein my Conscience is unsatisfied, then the sharp touches I have had for what passed Me, in My Lord of Straffords business.
Not that I resolved to have imployed him in My affairs, against the advise of my Parliament, but I would not have had any hand in his Death, of whose Guiltlesness I was better assured, then any man living could be.
Nor were the crimes objected against him so clear, as after a long and fair hearing to give convincing satisfaction to the Major part of both Houses; especially that of the Lords, of whom scarce a third part were present, when the bill passed that House: And for the House of Commons, many Gentlemen, disposed enough to diminish My Lord of Straffords greatness and power, yet unsatisfied of his guilt in Law, durst not condemn him to die: who for their integrity in their Votes, were by Posting their Names, exposed to the popular calumny, hatred and fury; which grew then so exorbitant in their clamours for Justice, (that is, to have both my self and the two Houses' Vote, and doe as they would have us) that many ('tis thought) were rather terrified to concur with the condemning party, then satisfied that of right they ought so to doe.
And that after-Act vacating the Authority of the precedent, for future imitation sufficiently tels the world, that some remorse touched even his most implacable enimies, as knowing he had very hard measure, and such as they would be very loath should be repeated to themselves.
This tendernesse and regret I find in my soul, for having any hand (and that very unwillingly God knows) in shedding one mans bloud unjustly, (though under the colour and formalities of Justice, and pretences of avoiding publick mischiefs) which may (I hope) be some evidence before God and man, to all posterity, that I am far from bearing justly the vast load and guilt of all that blood which hath been shed in this unhappy War; which some men will needs charge on me, to ease their own souls, who am, and ever shall be, more affraid to take away any mans life unjustly then to lose my own.
But then, O God, of thy infinit mercies forgive me that act of sinfull compliance, which hath greater aggravations upon me then any man, Since I had not the least temptation of envy, or malice against him, and by my place should, at least so farre, have been a preserver of him, as to have denied my consent to his destruction.
O Lord, I acknowledge my transgression, and my sin is ever before me.
Deliver me from blood-guiltiness O God, thou God of my salvation, and my tongue shall sing of thy righteousness.
Against thee have I sinned, and done this evil in thy sight, for thou sawest the contradiction between my heart and my hand.
Yet cast me not away from thy presence, purge me with the blood of my Redeemer, and I shall be clear; wash me with that pretious effusion, and I shall be whiter then snow.
Teach me to learn Righteousnesse by thy Iudgements, and to see my frailtie in thy Iustice: while I was perswaded by shedding one mans bloud to prevent after-troubles, thou hast for that, among other sins, brought upon mee, and upon my Kingdoms, great, long, and heavy troubles.
Make me to prefer Iustice, which is thy Will, before all contrary clamours, which are but the discoveries of mans injurious will.
It is too much that they have once overcome me, to please them by displeasing thee: O never suffer me for any reason of State, to go against my Reason of Conscience, Which is highly to sin against thee, the God of Reason, and Iudge of our Consciences.
Whatever, O Lord, thou seest fit to deprive me of, yet restore unto me the joy of thy Salvation, and ever uphold me with thy free Spirit; which subjects my will to non: but the light of Reason, Justice, and Religion, which shines in my Soul; for thou desirest Truth in the inward parts, and Integritie in the outward expressions.
Lord, hear the voice of thy Sons, and my Saviours bloud, which speaks better things; O make me, and my People, to hear the voice of Joy and Gladness, that the bones which thou hast broken, may rejoice in thy salvation.
Scripture echoes
- ↩Ps.51.3 — Be gracious to me, O God, according to your steadfast love; according to your abundant mercy, blot out my transgressions.
- ↩Ps.51.7 — Behold, in iniquity I was brought forth, and in sin my mother conceived me.
- ↩Heb.12.24 — and to Jesus, mediator of a new covenant, and to the sprinkled blood that speaks a better word than Abel's
- ↩Ps.51.8 — Behold, You desire truth in the inward parts, and in the hidden places You will teach me wisdom.
Notes
- 1 ↩Source 'then' is Early Modern spelling for 'than' in the rather/than comparison; rendered as 'than'.
- 2 ↩Source 'unsatisfiedness in Conscience' rendered as 'dissatisfaction in conscience' (unease / incomplete assent of conscience, not mere mood).
- 3 ↩Source 'plenary consent' rendered as 'full consent' (complete, unqualified assent), distinguishing it from mere 'compliance'.
- 4 ↩Source 'then' modernized as comparative 'than'; 'bare' as past of bear/feel; 'publick convenience' kept as public convenience/advantage, in deliberate parallel with 'inconveniences of the state'.
- 5 ↩Source 'then' is the Early Modern spelling of comparative 'than' (not temporal 'then'); rendered as 'than'.
- 6 ↩'ingratiatings with the People' rendered as 'attempts to win the people's favor' (acts of ingratiation). 'vote of My own Conscience' rendered as 'judgment of my own conscience' (the conscience's decided counsel, not a parliamentary vote).
- 7 ↩Early Modern 'what passed Me' is rendered as 'what I allowed' (what I let go forward / consented to); the neighboring sections frame this as an unjust act regarding Strafford that now stings the conscience.
- 8 ↩Source 'then' is the Early Modern spelling of comparative 'than'.
- 9 ↩after-Act: the subsequent parliamentary Act that nullified the legal force of Strafford’s attainder as a usable precedent; hard measure: harsh, unequal treatment.
- 10 ↩Early Modern 'clear' here means cleansed/clean (Psalm 51 sense), not transparent or free of suspicion; 'pretious effusion' is the precious outpouring of the Redeemer's blood; source 'then' is the older spelling of 'than'.
- 11 ↩Source reads "to non: but the light"; taken as corrupt/early spelling of "none but" (subjects my will to nothing except the light of reason, justice, and religion).
Eikon Basilike: The Pourtraicture of His Sacred Majestie in His Solitudes and Sufferings companion
A prayer for every moment, already on your phone
Chosen Portion puts a curated historic prayer in front of you each day — so the words are there before the moment arrives.
Chosen Portion is the digital descendant of the carried prayer book: the short daily prayers this collection preserves, delivered one a day to your pocket.
- One short, memorable prayer delivered daily — build your repertoire a card at a time
- Prayers matched to real situations: fear, gratitude, decisions, grief, sleep
- Save favourites into your personal pocket collection you can open anywhere