Upon the various events of the War; Victories, and Defeats
Providence in the Midst of Conflict
The King reflects on how God uses both victory and defeat to test his patience and humble his heart.
The changing fortunes of this unhappy war have at least given me a variety of good meditations. Sometimes God was pleased to test me with victory by defeating my enemies, so that I might learn how to acknowledge and use His power with moderation and gratitude—He who is the only true Lord of Hosts, able to check the confidence of those who fought against me with such an advantage in power and numbers whenever He pleases.1 From my own small beginnings, he let me see that I wasn't entirely forsaken by my people's love, or by his protection. At other times God was pleased to try my patience, and to teach me not to trust in the arm of flesh, but in the living God. Sometimes my sins prevailed against the justice of my cause, and those who were with me did not lack grounds or occasion for His just chastisement of both them and me. Nor were my enemies any less punished by that prosperity which hardened them to continue that injustice through open hostility—hostility that was begun by the most riotous and unparliamentary tumults. There's no doubt that personal and private sins can often outweigh the justice of public engagements; nor does God count every gallant man—in the world's esteem—a fit instrument to uphold a righteous cause through war. The more men are prone to claim credit for their own skill, valor, and strength, the less God ordinarily works through them for his own glory. I'm sure the outcome or success can never establish the justice of any cause, nor the peace of men's consciences, nor the eternal fate of their souls.
The Integrity of a Just Cause
The King defends the legitimacy of his cause while distinguishing true martyrdom from the rebellion of his enemies.
Those who stood with me had, I think, clearly and beyond doubt what justified them: the Word of God, the laws of the land, and their own oaths—all requiring obedience to my just commands, but to no one else under heaven without me, or against me, on the point of raising arms. Those on the other side are forced to resort to the expedients of some pretended fears and wild fundamentals of state (as they call them), which actually overthrow the present fabric of both Church and State—being such imaginary reasons for self-defense as are wholly unfitting for those men to allege who, being my subjects, were plainly the first to assault me and the laws: first by leaving the tumults unsuppressed, afterward by enlisted forces. The same allegations they use will fit any faction that has only power and confidence enough to back with the sword all its demands against the present laws and governors, which can never be so sound that some side or other will not find fault with them, so as to push what they call a reformation of them into a rebellion against them. Some parasitic preachers have dared to call those martyrs who died fighting against me, the laws, their oaths, and the established religion.23 But sober Christians know that this glorious title can truly be applied only to those who sincerely put God's truth and their duty in all these particulars above their lives, and above everything dear to them in this world—those who, having no self-serving designs through any innovation, were religiously aware of those ties to God, the Church, and me that rested on their souls, both for obedience and for just assistance.45 God could—and I don't doubt that through his mercy he did—crown many of them with eternal life whose lives were lost in such a just cause; the destruction of their bodies was sanctified as a means to save their souls. Their wounds and worldly ruin serve as a gracious opportunity for their eternal health and happiness; while the clear approach of death, through God's grace, effectively disposes their hearts to such humility, faith, and repentance as, together with the rightness of their present cause, would fully prepare them for a better life than the one their enemies' brutish and disloyal fierceness could take from them—or that those enemies could hope to enjoy without repentance.67 They have often, in fact, had the upper hand against me on the battlefield, but I believe never at the bar of God's tribunal, or before their own consciences—where they are more afraid to face those many weighty reasons, based on law, allegiance, and all true Christian grounds, which clash with them and accuse them in their own thoughts, than they often were, in desperate boldness, to fight against those forces which God sometimes gave me.8 I have no doubt that for any sober person who truly values their duty, their soul, and eternity over the pleasures of this life, the condition of those who have been conquered and are dying is infinitely preferable to the most triumphant glory in which their enemies and mine still live. These enemies can hardly escape being tormented every day by the horrific guilt that haunts their uneasy or now-convicted consciences, especially since they and the whole world have seen how false and insincere the claims were that they first used as the only plausible—though not justifiable—grounds for starting a war and continuing it this long against me and the established laws, in whose safety and preservation all honest people believe the welfare of their country consists. For, and with all of this, it is far more honorable and comforting to suffer than to prosper through their ruin and overthrow.9
A Prayer for Self-Mastery and Peace
The King expresses his desire for peace and his prayer that he might prioritize victory over his own sinful nature above military conquest.
I’ve often prayed that everyone on my side might combine true piety with a real sense of their loyalty, and be as faithful to God and their own souls as they were to me—so that the defects of the one wouldn't blight the efforts of the other. Yet I can't think that any shows of true piety on the other side were enough to excuse, or atone for, the failings of their duty and loyalty to me—which press so forcefully on men's consciences that even more irreligious men are moved by the sense of them to risk their lives for me. I never had a victory that was free of sorrow, because it was won against my own subjects, many of whom, like Absalom, died in their sin. And yet, I never suffered a defeat that made me despair of God's mercy and defense. I never wanted victories for the sake of conquest; I only wanted those that would restore the laws and liberties of my people—which I saw were being crushed, along with my own rights, by men who refused to accept any just restraint. Whether Providence granted me a victory or denied me one, I never wanted to boast of my own power or foolishly blame God—for I trusted that, in the end, He would make all things work together for my good. I didn't want any greater advantage from the war than to bring my enemies to moderation and my friends to peace.10 I feared the temptation that comes with total conquest, and I never prayed for victory over others more than I prayed for victory over myself.11 When the first was denied, the second was granted me—which God saw was best for me. The different events were only the methods of divine justice, using contrary winds to winnow us: so that by punishing our sins he might purge them from us, and by delaying peace he might prepare us to prize it more and to use so great a blessing better.12 My frequent messages for peace showed that I took no pleasure in war; just as my earlier concessions amply proved how willingly I would have prevented it, and my total lack of preparation for it showed how little I intended it. The conscience of my innocence forbade me to fear a war; but love for my kingdoms commanded me, if possible, to avoid it. I'm guilty of nothing in this war but this: that I gave some men such advantages by confirming their power—power they didn't know how to use with the modesty and gratitude that their loyalty and my confidence in them called for. If I had yielded less, I would have faced less opposition; if I had denied more, I would have been obeyed more. It's too late now to revisit the causes of the war; I only wish for a happy end to such unhappy beginnings. The inevitable consequence of our sins was, no doubt, that divine Justice would no longer remain silent: having exhausted that patience, we are condemned by our mutual conquests to destroy one another—for even the most prosperous successes on either side only harm the welfare of the whole. Those victories are still miserable that leave our sins unsubdued—flushing our pride and animating us to keep doing harm. Peace isn't desirable in itself until repentance has prepared us for it. When we fight more against ourselves, and less against God, we'll stop fighting one another; I pray God these may all meet in our hearts and so prepare us for a happy end to these civil wars, that I may better know how to obey God and govern my people, and they may better learn to obey both God and me. Nor do I want anyone to be more subject to me than all of us may be subject to God.13
A Royal Supplication
The King concludes with a series of petitions, asking God for grace, patience, and the ultimate peace found in Christ.
O my God, make me content to be overcome when you will have it so. Teach me the noblest victory over myself and my enemies through patience, which was Christ's conquest and is truly fitting for a Christian king.14 Between your two hands—the right sometimes supporting, and the left afflicting—shape us into the kind of piety you prefer. Forgive the pride that comes with our prosperous outcomes, and the fretting that follows our disastrous ones—when we go out in our own strength, you withdraw yours and do not go out with our armies.15 Be everything when we are something, and when we are nothing, so that you may have the glory whether we are in a victorious or an inglorious condition.✦ Lord, you know how hard it is for me to suffer so much evil from my subjects, to whom I intend nothing but good; and I cannot help but suffer in those evils they compel me to inflict on them, punishing myself in their punishments.16 Since I suffer whether I conquer or am conquered, I ask you to give me a double portion of your Spirit, and that measure of grace which alone is enough for me. As I am most afflicted, make me most thoroughly reformed, so that I won't just be glad to see an end to these civil disorders, but may also be a primary instrument in restoring and establishing a firm and blessed peace for my kingdoms. Stir up in all parties pious ambitions to outdo one another with reason, moderation, and such self-denial as fits those who consider that our mutual divisions are the disorders we share in common, and that the union of all is every good man's highest interest.17 If, O Lord, just as You have brought the miseries of war upon us for the sins of our peace, You should also see fit to deny us the blessing of peace for the sins of war, and so keep us in a cycle of miseries, yet grant me, Your servant, and all loyal though afflicted subjects, to enjoy that peace which the world can neither give us nor take from us. Don't charge me with the blood of my subjects, which I have shed with boundless reluctance and grief in my just and necessary defense; instead, wash me with that precious blood shed for me by my great Peacemaker, Jesus Christ, who I trust will soon redeem me from all my troubles—for I know the triumph of the wicked lasts only a little while, and the joy of hypocrites is only for a moment.✦✦
Read the original Latin
The various successes of this unhappy war, have at least, afforded me variety of good meditations: sometimes God was pleased to try me with victory, by worsting my enemies, that I might know how with moderation and thanks to own, and use his power, who is the onely true Lord of Hosts, able when he pleases to represse the confidence of those who fought against mee with so great advantage for power and number.
From small beginnings on my part, hee let me see, that I was not wholly for saken by my peoples love, or his protection.
Other times God was pleased to exercise my patience, and teach me not to trust in the arm of Flesh, but in the living God.
My sins sometimes prevailed against the justice of my cause, and those that were with me wanted not matter and occasion for his just chastisement both of them and Mee: Nor were My Enemies lesse punished by that prosperity which hardened them to continue that injustice by open hostilitie, which was begun by most riotous and un-Parliamentary Tumults.
There is no doubt but personall and private sins may oft-times over-balance the Justice of publick Engagements; nor doth God account every gallant man (in the worlds esteem) a fit instrument to assert in the way of War a righteous Cause: The more men are prone to arrogate to their own skill, valour, and strength, the lesse doth God ordinarily work by them for his own glory.
I am sure the event or successe can never state the Justice of any Cause, nor the peace of mens Consciences, nor the eternall fate of their Souls.
Those with Me had (I think) clearly and undoubtedly, for their justification, the Word of God, and the Lawes of the Land, together with their own Oathes; all requiring obedience to my just Commands; but to none other under Heaven without me, or against me in the point of raising Arms.
Those on the other side are forced to flie to the shifts of some pretended Fears, and wilde Fundamentals of State (as they call them) which actually overthrow the present fabrick both of Church and State; being such imaginary Reasons for self-defence as are most impertinent for those men to alledge, who being my Subjects, were manifestly the first assaulters of Me and the Laws: first, by unsuppressing the Tumults, after by listed Forces: The same Allegations they use, will fit any Faction that hath but power and confidence enough to second with the Sword all their Demands against the present Laws and Governours; which can never be such as some side or other will not find fault with, so as to urge what they call a Reformation of them to a Rebellion against them: some parasitick Preachers have dared to call those Martyrs, who died fighting against Me, the Laws, their Oaths, and the Religion established.
But sober Christians know, That glorious Title can with truth be applied onely to those, who sincerely preferred Gods Truth and their duty in all these particulars before their lives, and all that was dear to them in this world; who having no advantageous Designes by any Innovasion, were Religiously sensible of those ties to God, the Church, and my Self, which lay upon their souls, both for obedience, and just assistance.
God could, and I doubt not but hee did through his mercy, crown many of them with eternall life, whose lives were lost in so just a Cause; the destruction of their bodies being sanctified as a means to save their souls.
Their Wounds and temporal Ruine serving as a gracious opportunity for their eternall Health and Happinesse; while the evident approach of death, through Gods grace, effectually dispose their hearts to such Humilitie, Faith, and Repentance, which together with the Rectitude of their present Engagement, would fully prepare them for a better life then that which their enemies brutish and disloyall fiercenesse could deprive them of; or without repentance hope to enjoy.
They have often, indeed, had the better against my side in the Field, but never, I beleeve at the Bar of Gods Tribunal, or their own Consciences; where they are more afraid to encounter those many pregnant Reasons, both for Law, Allegiance, and all true Christian grounds, which conflicts with, and accuse them in their own thoughts, then they oft were in a desperate bravery to fight against those Forces which sometimes God gave me.
Whose condition conquered, and dying, I make no question, but is infinitely more to be chosen by a sober man (that duly values his duty, his soul and eternity, beyond the enjoyment of this present life) then the most triumphant glory, wherein their and mine Enemies supervive; who can hardly avoid to be daily tormented by that horrid guilt, wherewith their suspicious, or now convicted Consciences do pursue them, especially since they and all the world have seen, how false and unintended those pretensions were, which they first set forth, as the onely plausible (though not justifiable) grounds of raising a War, and continuing it thus long against Me, and the Laws established; in whose safety and preservation all honest men think the welfare of their Country doth consist.
For, and with all which, it is far more honourable and comfortable to suffer, then to prosper in their ruine and subversion.
I have often prayed, that all on my side might join true pietie with the sense of their Loyalty; and be as faithfull to God and their own souls, as they were to Me; That the defects of the one might not blast the endeavours of the other.
Yet I cannot think, that any shews of truth of piety on the other side were sufficient to dispence with, or expiate the defects of their dutie and Loyaltie to Me, which have so pregnant convictions on mens consciences, that even profaner men are moved by the sense of them to venture their lives for Me.
I never had any Victory which was without My sorrow, because it was on Mine own Subjects, who, like Absolom, died many of them in their sin: And yet I never suffered any Defeat which made Me despair of Gods mercy and defence.
I never desired such victories, as might serve to conquer, but only restore the Laws and Liberties of My people; which I saw were extremly oppressed, together with my rights, by those men, who were impatient of any just restraint.
When Providence gave Me, or denied Me Victory, my desire was never to boast of my power nor to charge God foolishly; who I believed at last would make all things to work together for my good.
I wished no greater advantages by the War, then to bring my Enemies to moderation, and my Friends to peace.
I was afraid of the temptation of an absolute conquest, and never prayed more for Victory over others, then over my self. When the first was denied, the second was granted me, which God saw best for me.
The different events were but the methods of divine justice, by contrary winds to winow us: That, by punishing our sins, he might purge them from us; and by deferring peace, he might prepare us more to prize, and better to use so great a blessing.
My often Messages for Peace shewed, that I delighted not in Warre; as my former Concessions sufficiently testified, how willingly I would have prevented it; and My totall unpreparedness for it, how little I intended it.
The Conscience of my Innocence forbad Me to fear a Warr; but the love of my Kingdoms commanded me (if possible) to avoid it.
I am guilty in this War of nothing but this, That I gave such advantages to some men, by confirming their power, which they knew not to use with that modesty and gratitude, which became their loyalty and My confidence.
Had I yeelded lesse, I had been opposed lesse; had I denied more, I had been more obeyed.
'Tis now too late to review the occasions of the War; I wish only a happy conclusion of so unhappy beginnings: The inevitable fate of our sins was (no doubt) such, as would no longer suffer the divine Justice to be quiet: we having conquered this patience, are condemned by mutuall conquerings, to destroy one another: for, the most prosperous successes on either side, impair the welfare of the whole.
Those Victories are still miserable, that leave our sins unsubdued; flushing our pride, and animating to continue injuries.
Peace is not it self desirable, till repentance hath prepared us for it.
When we fight more against our selves, and lesse against God, we shall cease fighting against one another; I pray God these may all meet in our hearts, and so dispose us to an happy conclusion of these Civil-Wars; that I may know better to obey God, and govern my people, and they may learn better to obey both God and me.
Nor do I desire any man should be further subject to me, then all of us may be subject to God.
O my God, make me content to be overcome, when thou wilt have it so.
Teach me the noblest victory over my self and my enemies by patience, which was Christs conquest, and may well become a Christian King.
Between both thy hands, the right sometimes supporting, and the left afflicting, fashion us to that frame of Piety thou likest best.
Forgive the pride that attends our prosperous, and the repinings which follow our disastrous events; when going forth in our own strength thou withdrawest thine, and goest not forth with our Armies.
Be thou all, when we are something, and when we are nothing; that thou mayest have the glory, when we are in a Victorious, or inglorious condition.
Thou O Lord knowest, how hard it is for me to suffer so much evill from my Subjects, to whom I intend nothing but good; and I cannot but suffer in those evils which they compel me to inflect upon them; punishing my self in their punishments.
Since therefore both in conquering, and being conquered, I am still a Sufferer: I beseech thee to give me a double portion of thy Spirit, and that measure of grace, which only can be sufficient for me.
As I am most afflicted, so make me most reformed: that I may not be only happy to see an end of those civill distractions, but a chief Instrument to restore and establish a firm, and blessed Peace to my Kingdoms.
Scirre up all Parties pious ambitions to overcome each other with reason, moderation, and such self-deniall, as becomes those, who consider that our mutuall divisions are our common distractions, and the Union of all is every good mans chiefest interest.
If O Lord, as for the sins of our peace, thou hast brought upon us the miseries of War: so for the sins of War thou shouldst see fit still to deny us the blessing of peace, and so to keep us in a circulation of miseries: yet give me thy Servant, and all Loyall, though afflicted Subjects, to enjoy that peace which, the world can nether give to us, nor take from us.
Impute not to me the blood of my Subjects, which with infinite unwillingness and griefe, hath been shed by me, in my just & necessary defence: but wash me with that precious blood, which hath been shed for me, by my great Peacemaker, Jesus Christ; Who will, I trust, redeem me shortly out of all my troubles: for, I know the triumphing of the Wicked is but short, and the joy of Hypocrites is but for a moment.
Scripture echoes
- ↩1Cor.15.28 — When all things are subjected to him, then the Son himself will also be subjected to the one who subjected all things to him, so that God may be all in all.
- ↩Job.20.5 — For the rejoicing of the wicked is brief, and the joy of the godless lasts but a moment.
- ↩Ps.25.22 — Redeem Israel, O God, from all their troubles.
Notes
- 1 ↩Early modern “successes” here means the various outcomes/fortunes of the war (not victories alone), matching the chapter’s “Victories, and Defeats.” “Own … his power” means acknowledge the power as God’s, not claim it as one’s own.
- 2 ↩Early modern 'unsuppressing' is rendered as leaving the tumults unsuppressed—i.e., failing to put them down—rather than actively fostering them, though the charge implies culpable inaction.
- 3 ↩'Listed' here means enrolled or recruited troops (raised armies), not a written list in the modern sense.
- 4 ↩Source 'Religiously sensible of' means devoutly/conscientiously aware of the weight of obligation, not 'sensible' in the modern practical sense; rendered 'religiously aware' to keep both piety and moral perception.
- 5 ↩Source spelling 'Innovasion' normalized to 'innovation' (unauthorized change in church or state order).
- 6 ↩Early Modern 'Health' here is spiritual well-being/salvation, not merely bodily recovery; kept as 'health' to preserve the contrast with temporal ruin and the pairing with happiness.
- 7 ↩'Engagement' rendered as 'cause' (their present military/political commitment); 'Rectitude' as 'rightness' for plain contemporary force without softening the moral claim.
- 8 ↩Early modern 'pregnant Reasons' rendered as 'weighty reasons' (full of force/import), not physical pregnancy; 'desperate bravery' as 'desperate boldness' (reckless courage/bravado).
- 9 ↩Early modern 'comfortable' is rendered as 'comforting' (consoling to conscience), not physical ease; 'then' is the period spelling of 'than'.
- 10 ↩Source 'then' is the early modern comparative spelling of 'than' and is rendered as 'than'.
- 11 ↩Period spelling 'then' is the comparative 'than'; 'my self' is modernized to 'myself'.
- 12 ↩Source 'winow' is period spelling of 'winnow' (to separate chaff from grain by wind); rendered in that sense.
- 13 ↩Early modern 'then' is comparative 'than' here (not temporal).
- 14 ↩Early modern 'become' here means 'befit/suit,' not 'turn into'; rendered 'befit' for contemporary clarity.
- 15 ↩Source has elliptical 'our prosperous' parallel to 'our disastrous events'; rendered as prosperous outcomes, with 'events/ones' carrying both members of the contrast. 'Repinings' rendered as fretting (discontented complaint), not mere sadness.
- 16 ↩Source reading 'inflect' is almost certainly an early-modern misprint or spelling for 'inflict'; sense rendered accordingly.
- 17 ↩Source opens with "Scirre up," which is almost certainly a corrupt reading of early modern "Stirre up" ("Stir up"); translated from that intended sense.
Eikon Basilike: The Pourtraicture of His Sacred Majestie in His Solitudes and Sufferings companion
A prayer for every moment, already on your phone
Chosen Portion puts a curated historic prayer in front of you each day — so the words are there before the moment arrives.
Chosen Portion is the digital descendant of the carried prayer book: the short daily prayers this collection preserves, delivered one a day to your pocket.
- One short, memorable prayer delivered daily — build your repertoire a card at a time
- Prayers matched to real situations: fear, gratitude, decisions, grief, sleep
- Save favourites into your personal pocket collection you can open anywhere