CHAP. XXXIV. The Parson's Dexterity in applying of Remedies.
The Christian's Two States and the Parson's Response
The Parson discerns whether his flock is in a military state of temptation or a peaceable state of joy, and applies appropriate remedies.
The Country Parson knows that even in this life a Christian has a double state: the one military, the other peaceable. The military is when we are assaulted with temptations either from within or from without; the peaceable is when the Devil leaves us for a time, as he did our Savior, and the angels serve us their own food—even joy and peace, and comfort in the Holy Spirit. These two states were in our Savior not only at the beginning of his preaching, but afterward as well, as Matthew 22. 35. He was tempted. And Luke 10.1 21.2 He rejoiced in the Spirit. And they must likewise be in all who are his.✦ Now the Parson, possessing spiritual judgment, adapts his approach to each person depending on which of the two states he finds them in. He advises those he finds in a peaceable state to be very vigilant, and not to drop the reins as soon as the horse starts moving easily. In particular, he gives them two pieces of advice: first, to be careful that their peace doesn't betray them (as it tends to do) into coldness and carelessness in their devotions, but instead to keep laboring to be as fervent in Christian duties as they remember being when affliction was blowing on the coals. Secondly, not to take the full range and liberty of their peace: not to eat every dish at table that their present health would otherwise allow; nor to fill their house with every piece of furniture that their present wealth would otherwise allow; nor, when among merry company, to indulge in all the mirth that the present occasion of wit and company would otherwise allow; but to set bounds and hoops on their joys: so they will last longer, and when they leave, they'll return sooner.3 If we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged; and if we would bound ourselves, we should not be bounded. But if they fear that at some time their peace and mirth carried them beyond this moderation, then let them take Job's admirable approach, who made sacrifices in case his children had transgressed in their merrymaking. So let them go and find some poor afflicted soul, and be generous and liberal there; for with such sacrifices God is well pleased. The Parson fortifies and strengthens those he finds in the military state with his utmost skill.
Remedies for Atheism: Arguments from Nature, Law, and Grace
For those tempted to doubt God's providence, the Parson offers threefold arguments from the order of creation, the witness of the Jewish people, and fulfilled prophecy.
Now among those who are tempted, whatever is unruly falls under two heads: either they think that no one can or will look after things, and that everything goes by chance or cleverness; or else, though there is a great Governor of all things, to them he is lost—as if they said, God forsakes and persecutes them, and there is no one to deliver them. If the Parson suspects the first and finds sparks of such thoughts emerging now and then, then without confronting them directly (for arguing won't cure atheism) he weaves into his conversation three kinds of arguments: the first drawn from Nature, the second from the Law, the third from Grace. From Nature, he can't see how a house could be either built without a builder, or kept in repair without someone to maintain it. He can't possibly imagine how the winds could blow as hard as they possibly can, and the sea rage as fiercely as it can, and all things do everything they can—and all of this not only without the whole thing falling apart, but without any part failing, even by losing the regular seasons of summer and winter, planting time and harvest.4 No matter what the weather is like, we still have bread—sometimes more, sometimes less; and a careful Joseph could plan for that as well. He can't possibly see how someone who would believe in a Divinity if he had been present at the Creation of all things should believe it any less when he sees the preservation of all things. For preservation is a creation; and more than that, it is a continued creation, and a creation every moment. Secondly, for the Law: there may be drawn from it so clear a proof of Divinity, though little used, that the atheist or Epicurean can have nothing to say against it.5 The Jewish people still exist and are known: they have their Law and language, which bear witness to them, and they bear witness to it; they still practice circumcision to this day, and look for the promises in Scripture. Their homeland is also known—the places and rivers that others travel to and visit—but to them it is an impenetrable rock, an inaccessible desert. So if the Jews live on, all the great wonders of old live on in them—and then who can deny the outstretched arm of a mighty God?✦ especially since it's fair to doubt whether, given the stubbornness of the nation, their living at that time in their own country under so many miracles was stranger than their present exile and inability to live in their country.6 And it's worth noting that God intended this very thing: that the Jews should be his proof and witnesses, as he calls them, Isaiah 43. 12. And their very dispersion through all lands was intended not only as a punishment for them, but to stir others, by seeing them, to acknowledge God and his power—Psalm 59.7 11. And therefore this kind of punishment was chosen rather than any other. Thirdly, for grace. Besides the unbroken succession of holy men who have borne witness to the truth ever since the Gospel—and there is no more reason to distrust Saint Luke, Tertullian, or Chrysostom than Cicero, Virgil, or Livy—there are two prophecies in the Gospel that clearly prove Christ's divinity by their fulfillment: the one about the woman who poured the ointment on our Savior, which he said would never be forgotten but would be preached with the Gospel itself to all ages, Matt.8 26.✦ 13. The other concerns the destruction of Jerusalem, about which our Savior said that generation would not pass away until all was fulfilled, Luke 21. 32. Josephus's History confirms this, and the lasting force of that judgment is still plain.9 We might also add the preaching of the Gospel in all nations, Matthew 24. 14.
Remedies for Despair: The Unfailing Love of God
For those who fear God has abandoned them, the Parson points to God's love as Creator and Redeemer, offering two unshakable pledges.
which we see even miraculously brought about in these new discoveries, God turning men's greed and ambitions to carrying out his word.✦ Now a prophecy is a wonder sent to later generations, so they won't complain of a lack of wonders.10 It is a sealed letter sent on its way: to the carrier it is only paper, but to the one who receives and opens it, it is full of power. Anyone who saw Christ open a blind man's eyes saw no more of his divinity than the person who reads about the woman's ointment in the Gospel, or who sees Jerusalem destroyed.✦✦11 By developing some of these points and weaving them into his teaching at various times and occasions, the Parson settles wavering minds.12 But if he sees them nearer to despair than to atheism—not so much doubting that there is a God as doubting that God is theirs—then he plunges into the boundless ocean of God's love and the unspeakable riches of his loving-kindness.13 He has one unanswerable argument. If God hates them, he does so either as they are creatures—dust and ashes—or as they are sinful. As creatures, he must of necessity love them; for no perfect Artist has ever hated his own work. Because they are sinful, he must love them all the more; for despite his infinite hatred of sin, his Love overcame that hate, and with an exceedingly great victory—one that Creation did not need—he gave them love for love, even the Son of his love from his bosom of love.✦14 So man, whichever way he turns, has two pledges of God's love—so that every word may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses: one in his being, the other in his sinful being; and as this second is the more faulty in him, so it is the more glorious in God.✦ Everyone may certainly conclude that God loves them, until either they despise that love or despair of his mercy. No other sin is outside his love; but despising love must necessarily be outside it.15 Pushing his arm away is the only thing that leaves us unembraced.
Read the original English
THe Countrey Parson knows, that there is a double state of a Christian even in this Life, the one military, the other peaceable. The military is, when we are assaulted with temptations either from within or from without, The Peaceable is, when the Divell for a time leaves us, as he did our Saviour, and the Angels minister to us their owne food, even joy, and peace; and comfort in the holy Ghost. These two states were in our Saviour, not only in the beginning of his preaching, but afterwards also, as Mat. 22. 35. He was tempted: And Luke IO. 2I. He rejoyced in Spirit: And they must be likewise in all that are his.
Now the Parson having a Spirituall Judgement, according as he discovers any of his Flock to be in one or the other state, so he applies himselfe to them. Those that he findes in the peaceable state, he adviseth to be very vigilant, and not to let go the raines as soon as the horse goes easie. Particularly, he counselleth them to two things: First, to take heed, lest their quiet betray them (as it is apt to do) to a coldnesse, and carelesnesse in their devotions, but to labour still to be as fervent in Christian Duties, as they remember themselves were, when affliction did blow the Coals. Secondly, not to take the full compasse, and liberty of their Peace: not to eate of all those dishes at table, which even their present health otherwise admits; nor to store their house with all those furnitures which even their present plenty of wealth otherwise admits; nor when they are among them that are merry, to extend themselves to all that mirth, which the present occasion of wit and company otherwise admits; but to put bounds, and hoopes to their joyes: so will they last the longer, and when they depart, returne the sooner. If we would judg ourselves, we should not be judged; and if we would bound our selves, we should not be bounded. But if they shall fear, that at such, or such a time their peace and mirth have carryed them further then this moderation, then to take Jobs admirable Course, who sacrificed lest his Children should have transgressed in their mirth. So let them go, and find some poore afflicted soul, and there be bountifull, and liberall; for with such sacrifices God is well pleased. Those that the Parson findes in the military state, he fortifyes, and strengthens; with his utmost skill.
Now in those that are tempted, whatsoever is unruly, falls upon two heads; either they think, that there is none that can or will look after things, but all goes by chance, or wit: Or else, though there be a great Governour of all things, yet to them he is lost, as if they said, God doth forsake and persecute them, and there is none to deliver them. If the Parson suspect the first, and find sparkes of such thoughts now and then to break forth, then without opposing directly (for disputation is no Cure for Atheisme) he scatters in his discourse three sorts of arguments; the first taken from Nature, the second from the Law, the third from Grace. For Nature, he sees not how a house could be either built without a builder, or kept in repaire without a house-keeper. He conceives not possibly, how the windes should blow so much as they can, and the sea rage so much as it can, and all things do what they can, and all, not only without dissolution of the whole, but also of any part, by taking away so much as the usuall seasons of summer and winter, earing and harvest. Let the weather be what it will, still we have bread, though sometimes more, somtimes lesse; wherewith also a carefull Joseph might meet. He conceives not possibly, how he that would beleeve a Divinity, if he had been at the Creation of all things, should lesse beleeve it, seeing the Preservation of all things; For Preservation is a Creation; and more, it is a continued Creation, and a creation every moment. Secondly, for the Law, there may be so evident, though unused a proof of Divinity taken from thence, that the Atheist, or Epicurian can have nothing to contradict. The Jewes yet live, and are known: they have their Law and Language bearing witnesse to them, and they to it: they are Circumcised to this day, and expect the promises of the Scripture; their Countrey also is known, the places, and rivers travelled unto, and frequented by others, but to them an unpenetrable rock, an unaccessible desert.
Wherefore if the Jewes live, all the great wonders of old live in them, and then who can deny the stretched out arme of a mighty God? especially since it may be a just doubt, whether, considering the stubbornnesse of the Nation, their living then in their Countrey under so many miracles were a stranger thing, then their present exile, and disability to live in their Countrey. And it is observable, that this very thing was intended by God, that the Jewes should be his proof, and witnesses, as he calls them, Isaiah 43. 12. And their very dispersion in all Lands, was intended not only for a punishment to them; but for an exciting of others by their sight, to the acknowledging of God and his power Psalm 59. 11. And therefore this kind of Punishment was chosen rather then any other. Thirdly, for Grace.
Besides the continuall succession (since the Gospell) of holy men, who have born witness to the truth, (there being no reason, why any should distrust Saint Luke, or Tertullian, or Chrysostome, more then Tully, Virgill, or Livy;) There are two Prophesies in the Gospel, which evidently argue Christs Divinity by their success: the one concerning the woman that spent the oyntment on our Saviour, for which he told, that it should never be forgotten, but with the Gospel it selfe be preached to all ages, Matth. 26. 13. The other concerning the destruction of Jerusalem; of which our Saviour said, that that generation should not passe, till all were fulfilled, Luke 21. 32. Which Josephus's History confirmeth, and the continuance of which verdict is yet evident. To these might be added the Preaching of the Gospel in all Nations, Matthew 24. 14.
which we see even miraculously effected in these new discoveryes, God turning mens Covetousnesse, and Ambitions to the effecting of his word. Now a prophesie is a wonder sent to Posterity, least they complaine of want of wonders. It is a letter sealed, and sent, which to the bearer [REDACTED] but paper, but to the receiver, and opener, is full of power. Hee that saw Christ open a blind mans eyes, saw not more Divinity, then he that reads the womans oyntment in the Gospell, or sees Jerusalem destroyed. With some of these heads enlarged, and woven into his discourse, at severall times and occasions, the Parson setleth wavering minds. But if he sees them neerer desperation, then Atheisme; not so much doubting a God, as that he is theirs; then he dives unto the boundlesse Ocean of Gods Love, and the unspeakeable riches of his loving kindnesse. He hath one argument unanswerable. If God hate them, either he doth it as they are Creatures, dust and ashes; or as they are sinfull.
As Creatures, he must needs love them; for no perfect Artist ever yet hated his owne worke. As sinfull, he must much more love them; because notwithstanding his infinite hate of sinne, his Love overcame that hate; and with an exceeding great victory, which in the Creation needed not, gave them love for love, even the son of his love out of his bosome of love. So that man, which way soever he turnes, hath two pledges of Gods Love, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established; the one in his being, the other in his sinfull being: and this as the more faulty in him, so the more glorious in God. And all may certainly conclude, that God loves them, till either they despise that Love, or despaire of his Mercy: not any sin else, but is within his Love; but the despising of Love must needs be without it. The thrusting away of his arme makes us onely not embraced.
Scripture echoes
- ↩Luke.10.21 — In that same hour he rejoiced in the Holy Spirit and said, "I praise you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, that you have hidden these things from the wise and understanding and revealed them to infants; yes, Father, for such was your gracious will before you."
- ↩Exod.6.6 — Therefore say to the sons of Israel, 'I am the LORD, and I will bring you out from under the burdens of Egypt, and I will deliver you from their slavery, and I will redeem you with an outstretched arm and with great judgments.'
- ↩Matt.26.13 — Truly I tell you, wherever this gospel is proclaimed in the whole world, what she has done will also be told in memory of her.
- ↩Matt.24.14 — And this gospel of the kingdom will be proclaimed throughout the whole inhabited world, as a testimony to all the nations. And then the end will come.
- ↩Matt.26.13 — Truly I tell you, wherever this gospel is proclaimed in the whole world, what she has done will also be told in memory of her.
- ↩Luke.21.32 — Truly I tell you, this generation will not pass away until all these things take place.
- ↩John.1.18;Col.1.13 — No one has ever seen God; the only-begotten God, who is in the bosom of the Father, that one has made him known. Col.1.13 — He has rescued us from the dominion of darkness and transferred us to the kingdom of the Son he loves.
- ↩Deut.19.15;Matt.18.16;2Cor.13.1 — A single witness shall not rise up against a man for any iniquity or for any sin, in any sin that he sins; on the evidence of two witnesses or on the evidence of three witnesses a matter shall stand. Matt.18.16 — But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you, so that by the mouth of two or three witnesses every matter may be established. 2Cor.13.1 — This is the third time I am coming to you. By the mouth of two witnesses or three every word will be established.
Notes
- 1 ↩Source prints 'Luke IO'; read as Luke 10 (early-modern numeral forms I/O for 1/0).
- 2 ↩Source prints '2I.'; read as 21 (early-modern I for 1).
- 3 ↩"hoopes" (hoops) keeps Herbert's image of binding/casking joy so it keeps longer; rendered as "bounds and hoops" to preserve the figure.
- 4 ↩Source 'earing' is the older sense 'ploughing/seedtime,' paired with harvest; rendered 'seedtime' to keep the seasonal pair clear.
- 5 ↩Source 'unused' read as 'little used / rarely employed,' not as 'useless.'
- 6 ↩Source 'then' is comparative 'than'; 'disability' means inability/powerlessness, not modern medical disability.
- 7 ↩'exciting of others' rendered as 'to stir others' (arouse/prompt), not modern 'exciting' as thrilling.
- 8 ↩Source 'Tully' is the older English name for Cicero; rendered as Cicero for modern readers. 'Success' here means fulfillment/outcome of the prophecies, not worldly triumph.
- 9 ↩'Verdict' is kept in sense as the prophetic judgment on Jerusalem; rendered as 'judgment' for clarity while preserving the idea of a settled ruling still in force.
- 10 ↩Source 'least' is Early Modern for 'lest' (so that...not).
- 11 ↩Source 'then' is comparative 'than'.
- 12 ↩'Heads' means topics or main points of argument, not physical heads.
- 13 ↩First 'then' is comparative 'than' (nearer desperation than atheism); second 'then' is the logical consequence.
- 14 ↩Herbert's cascade of 'love' is deliberate rhetoric: God's Love conquers his hate of sin and gifts the Son ('the son of his love') from 'his bosom of love.' 'Which in the Creation needed not' means this redemptive victory was unnecessary at Creation, when there was no sin to overcome.
- 15 ↩Source construction 'not any sin else, but is within his Love' means every sin but one remains within the reach of God's love; despising that love (and despairing of mercy) places a person outside it.
A Priest to the Temple, or, The Country Parson companion
A prayer for every moment, already on your phone
Chosen Portion puts a curated historic prayer in front of you each day — so the words are there before the moment arrives.
Chosen Portion is the digital descendant of the carried prayer book: the short daily prayers this collection preserves, delivered one a day to your pocket.
- One short, memorable prayer delivered daily — build your repertoire a card at a time
- Prayers matched to real situations: fear, gratitude, decisions, grief, sleep
- Save favourites into your personal pocket collection you can open anywhere